Walking your dog is one of life’s simple joys. But when it comes to whether to use a harness or a collar, the decision can leave even the most seasoned dog owners scratching their heads. The debate over which one is better for your pup’s daily stroll is a common one, and choosing between the two isn’t always as clear-cut.
That’s why we’re here to break down the pros and cons of each option. And if you're after a new one, dog collars from Dog Friendly Co. offer a range of options, so you can find the perfect one for your dog.
A Closer Look at Dog Collars
Dog collars are a must-have for your pup, with plenty of practical uses that go way beyond just looking cute. This simple, adjustable band wraps around your dog’s neck and is typically made from materials like nylon, leather, or fabric. Collars serve multiple purposes, from holding ID tags and attaching a leash, to being used for training in certain cases.
Types of Collars
- Flat Collars: The most common type, these collars are lightweight and are perfect for everyday wear. They allow you to attach a leash for walks, plus they’re the go-to for holding ID tags.
- Martingale Collars: These are a great option for dogs with narrow heads as they provide a bit more control by gently tightening when the dog pulls without choking them.
- Training Collars: Variations include prong collars or choke chains, which are typically used in training sessions to help correct undesired behaviour. These should only be used under professional guidance, however, as misuse can potentially harm dogs.
When is the best time to use a dog collar?
- Everyday Wear: Collars are not only practical for attaching a leash when you’re out and about, but also provides a constant spot for your dog’s ID tag, making it an essential part of their everyday gear.
- Identification (ID tags): If your pup ever decides to go on an unplanned adventure, attaching their ID tags to a collar ensures they can be easily identified and safely returned home.
- Leash Attachment for Walks: Of course, collars are used to attach the leash when you’re going for walks. Whether it’s a stroll around the block or an adventure in the park, collars help keep your dog safe and under control.
The Rundown on Dog Harnesses
A dog harness is a snug, adjustable piece of gear that wraps around your dog’s body. Unlike collars, harnesses distribute pressure more evenly, making them a gentler option for walks. They’re also the preferred choice for dogs who tend to pull, as they give more control and help prevent neck strain.
Types of Harnesses
- Front-Clip Harness: This type of harness has a leash attachment on the front of your dog’s chest, so you can guide them back toward you if they pull. It’s great for training as it discourages pulling and gives you more control during walks.
- Back-Clip Harness: A back-clip harness has the leash attachment on the dog’s back, making it ideal for more relaxed strolls around the park. This style is also better for well-behaved dogs who don’t pull, as it allows them to walk freely without too much restriction.
- Step-In Harness: These harnesses are perfect for dogs who might not like putting on their gear. Your pup just steps into the harness, and it fasters around their body; simple as that. It’s an excellent option if your dog constantly needs quick gear adjustments.
- No-Pull Harness: If your dog’s a bit of a puller, this harness can be a game-changer. With its unique design, it redirects the pressure when your dog pulls, helping to discourage the behavior.
When is the best time to use a dog harness?
- During Walks: Harnesses are often the way to go for most walks, especially if your dog tends to pull or has a sensitive neck. Their design spreads out the pressure, making the whole walk more comfortable for your pup.
- Better Control: If your dog is a bit excitable or likes to dart off, harnesses give you more control. With a secure fit, you’ll have a better grip and can steer your pup a lot easier.
- Safety First: Is your dog a puller or has breathing issues? Harnesses are a better option as they take the pressure off the neck and help avoid injuries or any discomfort.
The Perks of Walking Your Dog with a Collar
A collar’s simplicity can’t be beaten—just slip it on, and you're ready to go. But what makes collars such a handy option? Let’s take a closer look:
Collars are easy to slip on and off.
When you’re in a rush or just after a simple solution, a collar is a quick, no-fuss option. No need for complicated straps or adjustments—just a simple fit and you’re out the door in no time.
A collar is the perfect place for ID tags.
If your dog ever decides to explore the neighbourhood solo, having an ID tag attached to their collar is a lifesaver. It’s the easiest way to make sure your dog is safe and can be quickly returned home if they ever wander off.
Collars are ideal for dogs who don’t pull.
For well-mannered pups who walk nicely by your side, a collar gives enough control without feeling restrictive. If your dog doesn’t pull or lunge, a collar’s all you need to keep your daily walks calm and easy.
They’re also great for smaller dogs.
If you’ve got a smaller breed, collars can be just the right fit as they provide comfort and security without the added bulk of a harness. It’s simple, lightweight, and perfect for those tiny frames.
Benefits of Walking Your Dog with a Harness
Some dogs strut like they own the footpath, while others lunge at every passing leaf. Either way, a harness can make walks a whole lot easier for both of you.
A harness helps protect your dog’s neck and throat.
Because a harness spreads pressure more evenly, it helps prevent strain on the neck, especially for dogs that pull or are prone to throat issues. This makes your walks safer and more comfortable, particularly for small breeds.
You’ll have better control, especially with excitable dogs.
A harness gives you more say over where your dog is going, without any harsh yanking on their neck. This makes it a great choice for bigger breeds or dogs who like to take the lead.
It’s a safer option for dogs with breathing problems.
For breeds like pugs or bulldogs, who already have enough trouble catching their breath, a collar can make things worse. A harness avoids unnecessary pressure on the throat, making it a more comfortable (and safer) choice.
A front-clip harness can help discourage pulling.
If your dog thinks walking means dragging you along for the ride, a front-clip harness can help. By redirecting them when they try to pull, it encourages better walking habits, without turning every outing into a strength competition between you two.
Harnesses are more comfortable for longer walks.
For dogs with short coats or sensitive necks, collars can get uncomfortable over time. Having a well-fitted harness for long strolls means less chafing and more comfort, as it sits securely around the body without digging in.
The Drawbacks of Using a Collar
A collar might be the classic choice, but for some dogs, it’s a daily test of how much pressure their throat can handle.
Pressure on the Neck and Throat
When a dog pulls against a collar, all that force is concentrated on one spot—their neck. This can strain the throat, spine, and airways, especially for smaller dogs or breeds prone to trachea issues. Even for bigger dogs, repeated pressure in this area isn’t exactly great for their long-term comfort.
Not Ideal for Pullers
If your dog treats every walk like a sprinting competition, a collar won’t do them (or you) and favours. Constant pulling can lead to discomfort and choking, with some dogs even learning to brace against the tension, making their pulling even worse.
Limited Control for Larger Dogs
For big or strong dogs, a collar doesn’t give you much leverage. If your dog suddenly takes off after something interesting, you’re left hanging on for dear life. A harness gives you more control, making it easier to steer them without a jarring yank on their neck, or yours.
Why a Harness Isn’t Always the Answer
Harnesses have their perks, but they’re not perfect—because let’s be honest, sometimes wrangling your dog into one feels like assembling furniture without the instructions.
More Time-Consuming to Put On
Unlike a simple buckle-and-go collar, harnesses usually have multiple straps, clips, and loops that need to be fastened just right. If your dog isn’t the patient type or if you’re running late, it can feel a bit of a hassle.
Can Be Bulky
While bigger dogs might not mind the extra gear, a hefty harness on a tiny pup can feel a bit too much. No-pull or full-body designs, in particular, can be a little clunky which your dog might find uncomfortable.
Adjustment Required
A harness that’s too loose can lead to escape attempts, while one that’s too tight can cause rubbing and irritation. Getting the right fit usually means a bit of adjusting and readjusting before it sits just right.
Cost and Maintenance
Harnesses also tend to cost more than collars and depending on the material, they might need more frequent cleaning. This is especially true if your dog has a talent for finding mud puddles.
So, Which Option is Best for Your Dog?
If dogs could weigh in on this debate, they’d probably just vote for no leash at all, but since that’s not an option, here’s what to consider when picking the right gear:
Small Dogs
Tiny dogs tend to do well with collars since they’re lightweight and simple. But if your dog has a delicate neck or struggles with breathing, a harness is a gentler option.
Large or Strong Dogs
A large or powerful dog in a collar can be tough to manage, especially if they get excited and decide to take off. A harness gives you better control while keeping pressure off their neck.
Pullers vs. Non-Pullers
If your dog treats every walk like a race, a front-clip harness can help steer them back on track. While it won’t fix pulling overnight, it can make training easier and walks a bit more enjoyable. If your dog already walks nicely on a leash, a collar might be all you need.
Training Needs
Working on leash manners? A harness is an excellent way to prevent strain or injury while your dog figures things out. It’s especially handy for excitable pups who tend to lunge at every bird, leaf, or passing stranger.
When to Use a Collar vs. a Harness
Picking between a collar and a harness isn’t about choosing sides; it’s about using the right tool for the job. Think of it like footwear: sometimes you need runners, sometimes slip-ons will do just fine. If your dog is relaxed on a leash and doesn’t pull, a collar is simple, comfortable, and convenient. It’s also handy for holding ID tags, so even if your dog wears a harness on walks, a collar is still a good everyday option.
Conversely, if your dog has a habit of pulling, a harness can help manage their enthusiasm without putting pressure on their neck. It’s also a better choice for puppies still learning leash manners or dogs with breathing issues, such as pugs or bulldogs. And if you’re heading out for a long walk, a well-fitted harness can be more comfortable for extended wear.
Harness or Collar? Sometimes the Answer is Both
Sometimes, the best option isn’t choosing one over the other, but using both. A collar is great for holding ID tags in case your dog ever goes on an unplanned adventure, while a harness gives you better control on walks—especially if your dog gets a bit too excited about passing birds, smells, or other dogs. Some owners even clip the leash to both for extra security, making it harder for even the craftiest escape artists to wriggle free.
Using both can also be helpful for training—letting you guide your dog with a harness while still having a collar for quick corrections or cues. This way, you get the benefits of both without putting too much strain on your dog’s neck or shoulders. It’s not about doubling up on gear for no reason; it’s about finding what works best for your dog and making walks as safe and comfortable as possible.
Finding the Right Fit for Your Dog
Walking your dog should be enjoyable, not a struggle with the wrong gear. Some dogs do just fine with a collar, while others are better off with a harness that offers more support and control. The best choice really depends on your dog’s size, behaviour, and any health concerns, such as breathing or a habit of pulling.
Instead of just picking one and hoping for the best, take a moment to consider your dog’s needs. Are they a relaxed walker, or do they like to charge ahead? Do they seem comfortable, or are they constantly scratching or resisting their gear? The right choice is one that makes walks enjoyable; for both you and your dog. At the end of the day, it’s not about the gear—it’s about the simple joy of walking side by side.
